Tag Archives: revolution

Romania – a revolution for evolution ?

It’s been a week already since the beginning of protests in Romania. Every day in Bucharest and in over 40 cities more Romanians go to the streets to express their dissatisfaction with the abuses of ruling regime and calling for the ouster of President Traian Basescu, as well as early elections. The explosion of discontent seems to have surprised the authorities. In fact, it is not surprising, but a crass lack of consideration for the citizens who elected them. We speak of a system with serious deviations from the laws of democracy (some amended by European Community institutions). It is a corrupt and arrogant regime. Proof – after week of protests the governments proves autistic to voice of people and have no relief solution to calm the thousands of protesters who are daily in the street in the cold with many minus degrees below zero. Proof – the main supporters of the system led by foreign minister of Romania, T. Baconschi, considered that the most intelligent way of social dialogue (so called by Prime Minister Boc) is to refer to the protesters with epithets such as «peripheral inept, worms, fanatics, ciumpalaci – I know that is untranslatable, a Romanian version of Lemmings».

A brief chronology of events

A bit over a year ago, Romanian watched peaceful to the people took to the streets in several countries across the ‘Arab world’ in what was later on called the ‘Arab Spring’. Then Romanians, apparently as impassive, watched on tv to Indignados and Ocuppy Wall Street movements in «mother» Europe and America. Nothing seemed to put the thoughts on the government while they imposed extreme austerity measures to the poorest populations of the European Union. President – Premier did not seem to notice that the cut of a pension of 1,000 euros (Greece) is a measure of austerity and cut a pension of 200 euros or below (Romania) is a crime. Aberrant measures had, however, and motivation: the IMF agreement. Motivations were found to suspend debate and dialogue between government and parliament. Then came the adoption of organic laws of vital importance by the government accountable without consulting parliament.

 Romania – faked democracy !

Before Christmas holiday appeared first discussions on a number of irregularities in Health Act which would be taken also without consulting parliament. Vigorous supporter of the existing project, President Basescu said on national television that the Deputy Health Ministry, Raed Arafat, is the main enemy of health system reform. Arafat, a Syrian Arab that has become a Romanian citizen, has distinguished himself by successfully founding the only professional emergency rescue service in Romania (SMURD), thereby embodying professionalism and moral standing in a healthcare system that is mostly regarded as book-example of corruption and oftentimes considered an expressway to the grave. Two weeks later, President Basescu with the usual habit to replace his Prime Minister and lead Romania as his own feud, intervened in the live TV debate vehemently criticized Arafat opinion and accused him of ‘leftist views’. The consequence of such a forceful televised intervention on behalf of President Basescu was that Arafat presented his resignation shortly afterwards. Next days discontent exploded. Initially the protests supporting of Raed Arafat and condemned the arrogance attitude and usual insolence of head of state. Facing public pressure, President Basescu decided to scrap the reforms Friday, saying he made the decision after realizing that a majority of those in the medical system and the population opposed to the change. It was certainly one new mistake of President Basescu. What head of state of the civilized world tells its people – who elected leader and those money he is paid – that is retrograde and unable to understand that governors wish him well when the people feel it’s becoming worse with every day ?

Tired of corruption systemic, theft unmasked and faked democracy, Romanians studded streets in over 60 cities in seven days of protest. They required the resignation of President Basescu and early elections. People chanted: Ultimate solution, once the revolution ! with reference to the revolution of 1989 when the communist regime was overthrown. Or, better, a revolution for evolution !  Or  ironic they say: Please excuse us, we do not produce how you steal ! Prime Minister Boc, Minister of Health and other government leaders have avoided for days to appear in public. Later they came just to throw invectives on the protesters or to mimic a dialogue with opposition forces. In an failed attempt to appease the spirits, PM said that he and the president have been misinformed on health law. But PM not said who is guilty of disinformation! Raed Arafat was reinstated in office. But useless. Although Romanians protest vehemently week, President Basescu (the same, which has usually the custom to intervene in all sorts of things that do not concern the duties of head of state) has avoided expressing an public opinion.

 The surgery was successful, the patient is in coma !

As protests intensified, the government tries to get cold while hoping that will deter the protesters and things will calm down. Next week will be a special session of Parliament. About the main demands of the population, Prime Minister Boc said that it is not justified. Noting that early elections would create a dangerous precedent and affect economic stability. In addition, he said that Romania would to become unattractive to investors. Romanian Prime Minister seems completely unrealistic. In which civilized and democratic countries early elections are a dangerous precedent ? What attractive business environment it is, if in 2011 the volume of foreign investments in Romania fell by 36% ? Oh, yes, the EU and IMF demanded austerity in Romania and government conformed – now there are riots and 18% of Romanian  live below the poverty line (compared to Czech – 2% Ireland – 4%​​), and austerity measures decreased purchasing power of Romanians with over 9% in a year – according to a survey of the Institute for Quality Research of life. Two million Romanian workers are at risk of poverty. To get a clearer view: in the UK an employee who lives in poverty earns 967 euros monthly, a Romanian poor employee earns 159 euros, achieving the lowest minimum wage in EU countries. Minimum wage in Bulgaria is 233 euros and 326 euros in Poland. In conclusion: the surgery was successful, the patient is in coma !

 Functional hypocrisy and dual attitude

“One year ago, President Ben Ali of Tunisia became the first casualty of the 2011 Arab Spring. Could we now be witnessing in Romania the first shoots of a European Spring?” asked editor Neil Clark from The Week – UK Edition. Although Romania is far from being a genuine democracy, I think such a comparison is inappropriate, however. We can speak rather an evolution than a revolution, if the “orange” regime in Bucharest would accept the democratic rules of the game. But if not? It seems that for evolution will be needed a new revolution. No matter how unpleasant it may sound.

Of course, the disturbances are undoubtedly embarrassing for the EU, the IMF and those western leaders for whom the Romanian government has been a staunch ally. Of course, hypocrisy and dual attitude of foreign partners are operating in this case. In contrast to neighboring Hungary, Romania accepted all that was dictated from abroad, whether we refer to U.S. strategic partner, the European partners or high finance world. Romanian Government had nothing to comment even when they have asked to implement abberant measures against  their own people. Thus it is easy to understand why European leaders immediately warned the government in Budapestat the recent protests of the population. But in respect of tandem Basescu – Boc, except for discrete requirement that Romanian head of state to express their opinion, European partners prove to be very “bashfully”. Although the deviations from the democracy line of leader in Bucharest are not far from those of Viktor Orban. Moreover, Europe has its own problems. Quite serious.

Neither the U.S. Embassy in Bucharest did not feel the need to say something, preferring only to follow the events. even if on his visit to the White House last September, President Basescu, a hard-core Atlanticist, was formally “congratulated” for signing up to the US-Romania Ballistic Missile Defence Agreement and the US-Romania Joint Declaration on Strategic Partnership for the 21st Century. An important partnership for U.S. in the context of an increasingly tense international atmosphere not only with Iran and Syria, but also with Russia (became an open supporter of the two countries). Moreover, a partnership that need to be fully functional regardless of who will occupy the chair of president of the state. The attitude of expectation may be due to the fact that potential substitutes (at least at this time) of President Basescu have strong pro-American view, so there is little reason to concern of Western Partnership. Clearly, the Romanian citizens matters less in this equation.

      So, Western leaders will prefer to wait and will be hoping that the Romanian government can survive the current disturbances. They can not condemn a people who demand the right to decency and respect from his politicians. Also they can not condemn the authorities – because in the next minute President Basescu would not hesitate to accuse the EU because irrational austerity measures required government in Bucharest.

Analysts said the protests are a sign of revival of  Romania civil society. I would say that this is an example of national and social solidarity. A successful example after several years of silence in which complaints have steadily accumulated. It is hardly to predict how it all will end in Romania. However, as noted Swedish political expert Vilhelm Konnander: “What I can’t help seeing is the pattern of protest that is spreading globally, where attitudes of politicians, blaming external factors for crisis, lead to higher demands for accountability. To whom are political leaders responsible – the people of the IMF, EU, etc.? It will be interesting to see how this turns out in Romania, but the basic observation seems to be that far too many politicians have forgot whom they are answering to”. The bad news for PM Boc and his colleagues in the governing Democratic Liberal party is that the disturbances show no sign of abating. Moreover, they could increase in intensity during the weekend. Of course, flagrant violations of human rights were a lot to the protests. Numerous attempts to intimidate participants in the protests, police abuses, frame-ups of violence to discredit the protests. Without success! At the moment the regime in Bucharest is autistic. Political power has made a few steps back. What’s next? Whether they fail slowly, step by step. Whether they will tense the muscles of authoritarian, knowing that however they do not have to lose more. If the 20 years of democracy, even mimed, meant something for the political class, they will fail. Government will be dismissed, it will form a government of technocrats and elections will be held – early or on time – but not cumulative way of local and parliamentary elections, as hoped the current government. And perhaps the most important thing of those described above: Romanians are reminded about good moral principles and values ​​that prevails in its heritage as a nation. It’s a good sign.

UPDATE: January 19, 15 p.m. (Bucharest time)

Romanian President Traian Basescu has met with the ambassadors accredited in Bucharest. He reminded about the Arab Spring, but completely ignored the protests which demand his resignation.

PublishedEurasia Review

Advertisements

Revolution of decency – Romania into Eastern European Spring

With some delay compared to the sister countries in European Union, Romania has entered into an Eastern European Spring. Thousands of Romanian staged a fourth day of protests in Bucharest and other 39 cities of country. Bucharest protest degenerated into violent clashes with police. 50 people were injured. Over 250 people were detained by police.

Ultimate solution, once the revolution !

In the last hour 500 students have joined the protesters. It requires the resignation of President Basescu and early elections. People chanted: Ultimate solution, once the revolution ! with reference to the revolution of 1989 when the communist regime was overthrown.

President Basescu has avoided expressing an opinion about protests. Protests started on Thursday in support of Deputy Health Minister Raed Arafat, who resigned this week after criticising the draft healthcare reform bill and being confronted by President Basescu, a supporter of the project. Afterwards the protests expanded from support for dr. Arafat to general discontent with the government’s unpopular austerity measures and too many dictatorial tendencies of the regime in Bucharest.

Sunday, January 15, at 20.30, co-president of Social-Liberal Alliance, Crin Antonescu, held a press conference in which called a extraordinary parliamentary session  and start the procedure for early elections . Protests have spread from University Square to Union Square.
Serious violence in Union Square
Sunday, January 15, at 22.00 :
The violences has taken a serious turn in Union Square in Bucharest.  Two policemen were seriously injured. “It is important for protesters to understand that we are not against them, we are here to protect them and … make sure the law is respected” said Georgian Enache, spokesman for Bucharest riot police, who added he didn’t have estimates as to how many protesters had gathered in downtown Bucharest.
The protesters have accused police of using unwarranted force. Interior Minister convened a crisis cell. 
Sunday, January 15, at 23.45:
Union Square – Anarchists have used stones and Molotov cocktails against the police. Number of victims of aggression in downtown reached 29, 15 have required hospitalization at University Hospital Emergency. Gangs of hooligans vandalized shops in the area. Some cars have been destroyed. Security forces used water cannons and tear gas trying to recover control of the area.
University Square – The protest continued peacefully.
Sunday, January 15, at 23.59:
Gendarmerie′s representatives intervened to disperse the protesters. Sanitation service machines began to clean the area. From the government has not yet been made ​​public an official opinion. The protesters announced that they will return tomorrow. Analysts said the protests are a sign of revival of  Romania civil society. I would say that this is an example of national and social solidarity. A successful example after several years of silence in which complaints have steadily accumulated.

Spring in Chisinau – where?

Candles Revolution

Twitter Revolution

Moldova is now part of a scenario known Romanian behind two decades. A peaceful demonstration of young Moldovan students degenerated into a mass revolt, with vandalism and violence. Protesters occupied the Parliament building and the Presidency. And destroyed all that they fell in their hands. Moreover, the Parliament building was much hours on fire. parlament_chisinauForces of order seemed overshadowed by the situation. Also President Voronin, whose speech was unsafe and lacking its usual arrogance. Even he given the impression of a person who tries to evade the reality of The Great National Assembly. Initial requests for invalidation of the election was turned into “Down Communism” and “Down Voronin”. And the building of President  has been put the European Union flag. And for this scenario to be complete, Voronin accused the opposition of “organizing violent demonstrations, which were planned long before and paid the money”, ie exactly means, “collaboration with foreign special agency that try destabilize the state “- allowed me qouted by defunct Ceauşescu. And appeared The Save National Committee, as composite as that of Romania’s in ’89.

Hence, scenario seems to differ. Probably because we are not dealing with a genuine communist regime, but rather with a harsh authoritarian regime based on corruption and satisfy their own interests, as communist ideology devoid of its original contents and used only a front for to cover numerous deviations from the canons of democracy. Thus, the authorities have agreed, after meeting with opposition leaders to move to recounted  the votes. Incomprehensible mistake of the opposition in Chisinau, which had to seek the invalidation of the election. Time required by the Commission for recounted election (10 days) will dilute the impact of events. That is exactly what the need Voronin for to reorganize and rechange the options. I will not comment pathetic picture of the opposition in Moldova and the haste with which they disclaim to young people in street protests. In fact, about the quality people of opposition can says a lot. But should take into account their legitimacy if they get power because to those young people.

However, days of the communist regime in Moldova appear to be numbered, no doubt. About call discussion with President Voronin, (made public by the Kremlin) Medvedev’s request  generated major questions about the support that it enjoys the Moldovan president to Moscow. The fact is that the calling Moscow to resolve the immediate situation of the peaceful and  stoping of violence coicide with the same request from the U.S. Department of State. But I would not rush to conclude (as I have already seen on some sites) that America has left Moldova on hand Russians.

A nation on the verge of despair  by a corrupt and still stuck in the past Soviet struggle brought for his release. But it depends how will to do this. Peaceful or violent. Scenario still remains open.

Conform moldavian sources, the protest will continue today.

P.S.: Demonstation of young people from Kishinev started as a viral message on the Internet. That stated on April 6 Day of National Mourning, and young people were called to light a candle in the Great Square of Chisinau. The call came from thousands of users in Moldova and Romania.
While the world watched with attention the events in Moldova, and the programs of TV news from abroad had dozens of breaking news on the subject, national television of Moldova presented entertainment programs for children. Such Life revolution has moved again on Internet, even if online communications were made with great weight.